Model before the bench
A simple mathematical model, built before the first experiment, is the cheapest experiment a team will ever run. Here is what it can tell you and how little mathematics it needs.
- CompetiLab Editorial
- 2 min read
Students hear "modeling" and imagine a wall of differential equations. In practice, the most useful models in a student synthetic biology project are small, built in an afternoon, and answer one question: is this design even plausible?
What a model is for
A model is a set of assumptions written down precisely enough to be calculated. Its value is not in predicting exact numbers, which it rarely does, but in three humbler services:
- Checking plausibility. If a sensor must detect a molecule at one micromolar and the model says the output would be indistinguishable from noise at that concentration, the team has learned something before ordering a single part.
- Finding what matters. Vary each parameter and see which ones change the result. Usually two or three dominate. Those are the ones to measure carefully; the rest can be estimated.
- Designing experiments that can fail. A model that predicts a response curve tells you which concentrations to test so that the result could actually contradict the design.
A worked sketch
Consider a whole-cell biosensor: a bacterium with a promoter that turns on in the presence of a target molecule, driving a fluorescent protein. The simplest model tracks one quantity, the amount of fluorescent protein, and says that it is produced at a rate that depends on the target concentration and degrades or dilutes at a constant rate.
In words: production minus loss. Production follows a saturating curve (a Hill function) of the target concentration, with a maximum rate, a half-saturation constant, and a steepness. Loss is proportional to how much protein is present.
With that, a spreadsheet can answer real questions. How long until the signal reaches half its final value? That depends almost entirely on the loss rate, which for a dilution-dominated culture is set by the growth rate. If the answer is three hours and the farmer in your Human Practices interviews needs thirty minutes, the design has a problem no amount of cloning will fix.
Parameters: where they come from
Published papers, part registries and databases list measured values for many parts. When nothing exists, estimate from a similar system and say so. A model built on honest, labeled guesses is still useful; the sensitivity analysis will tell you which guesses need to become measurements.
Keep it reproducible
Write the model as a short script or a clearly labeled spreadsheet, store it with the project, and record every parameter's source. When experimental data arrive, fit the model, compare, and update. The comparison between what the model predicted and what the bench produced is itself a result worth reporting, especially when they disagree.
Begin with a question.
Tell us what a student cannot stop thinking about. We will suggest where it could go.